Jack Brighton's Dissertation Defense
PhD candidate Jack Brighton will present his dissertation defense, "The CMS Black Box: Actor-Networks, Content Management Systems, and the Crisis in Local News." His dissertation committee includes Teaching Associate Professor Martin Wolske (Chair); Associate Professor Madelyn Rose Sanfilippo (Director of Research) Professor Kate McDowell; and Associate Professor Colin Rhinesmith.
Abstract
In the mid-2000s news organizations began adopting Content Management Systems (CMS) so journalists and non-technical staff can publish web pages regardless of coding skills. CMSs serve as a centralized system for news story composition and publishing to audiences across the World Wide Web and social media. With rapid growth in online audiences and their importance to news organizations, the work practices and organizational patterns the CMS both facilitates and requires became normalized in the production of online news. CMSs also typically integrate third-party platforms via software plug-ins and scripts embedded on web pages. Many of these technologies facilitate data connections with analytics, social media, and ad-tech platforms. This allows the platforms to capture, aggregate, and commodify personal data from news website audiences for use in profit-making activities such as targeted advertising and trade on data markets.
While previous studies have examined how journalists respond to changes in technology and their relationships with CMSs, this dissertation provides new insights to help explain how the CMS both reshapes news work and connects local journalism to the exploitive data practices of Big Tech platforms. Information history and actor-network theory (ANT) provide the conceptual framework in this study to uncover the mutual shaping of newsroom technologies and the journalists and institutions who use them. The methodology includes semi-structured oral history interviews with local journalists and newsroom technologists to investigate the relationships between technology platforms and local news organizations. Quantitative data from 123 news organization websites were analyzed to identify which CMS and third-party technologies were used.
Findings from the analysis show that every news CMS examined is configured with technologies that allow third-party platforms to exploit data from website visitors, and I find that these mechanisms and exploitive practices remain opaque to most local journalists as they use their organization’s CMS to produce and publish local news. In actor network theory terms, the news CMS has become a black box whose connections to third-party platforms have become normalized and no longer questioned. This study contributes to the journalism studies and information science scholarship by describing how the newsroom CMS emerges as a central actor in enabling the assimilation of news organizations into the actor-networks of Big Tech. The history of digital transformation presented in this study has significant implications for the future of news and information in an era increasingly dominated by AI technologies.
Questions? Contact Jack Brighton.