Gowri Balasubrammaniam’s Dissertation Defense
PhD candidate Gowri Balasubramaniam will present her dissertation defense, "'It can't really like feel feelings, but it can track them': Youth Encounters and Judgments of Artificial Intelligence in Everyday Life." Balasubramaniam's final examination committee includes Teaching Associate Professor Rachel Magee (Chair); Associate Professor Madelyn Rose Sanfilippo; Associate Professor Colin Rhinesmith; and Professor Michael Twidale.
Abstract
For young people, encounters with Artificial Intelligence (AI) are becoming features of everyday technology use rather than a deliberate choice, as AI systems and their logics increasingly shape their educational, social, and informational environments. Research on young people and their digital environments, especially AI, has navigated the tension between preventing harm and identifying risks on one hand, and recognizing young people’s agency and participation on the other, making protection and risk a longstanding lens for studying their experiences. Concurrently, regulatory frameworks varying in degree of enforcement from national policy to school and household rules shape the conditions of their engagement with AI systems. Despite being a significant stakeholder group with distinct ways of engaging with and using technologies, how they experience them and interpret rules remains understudied.
This dissertation focuses on young people's everyday experiences and looks at how they encounter and make sense of AI, how they think about safety, and how they judge the rules that shape their technology use. The study involved 17 participants aged 10 to 17 from five U.S. states. Participants first completed creative activity booklets at home and then took part in semi-structured interviews. The study design drew on commitments from critical youth studies and used participatory and co-design methods. Data from the booklets and interviews were analyzed together using thematic analysis. This analysis produced five main themes and offers an empirical account of youth experiences with AI, highlighting the norms and judgments they bring and the factors that affect whether they can act on those judgments.
The findings show that participants encountered AI within familiar technologies and document their accounts of assessing AI’s uses in their work, its behaviors, its use of personal information, and the legitimacy of rules around its use and access. Their accounts revealed expectations about appropriate assistance, interaction, information use, and protection. The findings also document conditions such as recognizing something as AI, having someone present to help, and other factors that shaped the circumstances in which young people made these judgments, and what kinds of judgments those circumstances made room for. The study findings distinguish young people’s capacity to evaluate the technologies and rules shaping their lives from their ability to influence the conditions under which they engage with them.
Questions? Contact Gowri Balasubramaniam.