Is code enough? Stodden, Marinov research focuses on providing code rather than generated data with research

Victoria Stodden
Victoria Stodden, Associate Professor

Sharing and reusing research data is becoming increasingly common in the scientific world, allowing researchers to more easily build on the work of others as they seek new discoveries.

A new research project being conducted by Associate Professor Victoria Stodden and Illinois Computer Science Professor Darko Marinov aims to answer key questions about how researchers can reliably share the code used to generate their data rather than the more costly data itself.

"Our question was, when is it possible to save only the code that produced simulated data, and that’s all I need to save, and when do I also need to save the data?" Stodden said. "Simulation codes can produce massive amounts of data, for example petabytes of data. If I can rerun the code and regenerate the data, in theory I don't even need to save the data. For what types of codes is that possible? That's exactly the question we're trying to answer."

The National Science Foundation is funding the work by Stodden and Marinov, providing $300,000 over two years. Stodden, who also is an Illinois Computer Science faculty affiliate, is the PI on the project. Marinov is the co-PI.

As Stodden, who is the lead investigator for the project, explains, the format for scholarly articles has changed little in decades. It provides only a small space to discuss how researchers derived their results.

But as computation has become more integral to research across virtually every scientific field, that format has become inadequate, she said.

"There's such an amount of complexity – the computer can do X calculations per second. So how do you actually explain the increased complexity of computational research in words in a small section in a paper? It can be very, very difficult," Stodden said.

Now some journals, she said, have begun to require researchers to publish their data and code along with their findings.

Stodden and Marinov, an expert on the testing and reliability of software, wondered whether providing the code alone could reliably allow the results of a given paper to be reproduced. And if it is the code that accompanies the published research, what kind of standard should it meet?

"If code is going to travel with this scholarly output, the community will need to come to some type agreement regarding code standards," she said.

For their project, the two are focusing on physics research as an example because of its intensive computational needs.

In preliminary work using articles from the Journal of Computational Physics, Stodden and her group tried to replicate the computational results from 55 articles and were unable to reproduce any. After contacting the authors, Stodden says they came away with the impression that many believed reproducing their computational results would be straightforward, something they found not to be the case.

Eventually, Stodden and Marinov hope to determine whether and how code could be reliably substituted for data for a wide range of fields.

"We want to learn how to do better scientific software, software that is more reliable, and that researchers can trust more," Stodden said. "These questions have come about not because the scientific community isn't doing a good job; they came about because computation is so important, and increasingly so. We're chasing fascinating opportunities here."

Research Areas:
Updated on
Backto the news archive

Related News

Illinois researchers to lead study on impacts of conservation investments

Conservation organizations and foundations have invested billions to preserve natural resources and biodiversity across the globe, but the effectiveness of these investments over time is not always clear. A new multi-institutional project, led by a University of Illinois researcher and supported by a $550,000 grant from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, will trace key outcomes of $655 million in the foundation's global conservation investments made over 40 years.

MacArthur grant team

Stodden coauthors National Academies report

Earlier this month, the U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine released a committee report examining computational reproducibility and replicability in science, with the goals of improving research rigor and transparency. The congressionally mandated report was authored by an ad hoc committee of national experts, including iSchool Associate Professor Victoria Stodden.

Victoria Stodden

National Humanities Center Fellowship supports Underwood book project

With support from the National Humanities Center, Professor Ted Underwood is examining patterns of human perspective throughout two centuries of literary history. The Center is a residential institute for advanced study in art history, classics, languages and literature, philosophy, and other fields of the humanities. In addition to pursuing their own research and writing at the Center, fellows form seminars and study groups with cohorts holding shared research interests.

Ted Underwood

iSchool names new MS program directors

The iSchool is pleased to announce the appointment of new directors for its master's degree programs. Associate Professor Maria Bonn will serve as program director for the MS in library and information science (MS/LIS), and Associate Professor Catherine Blake will serve as program director for the MS in information management (MS/IM). They will begin their three-year terms on May 16.

He to join iSchool faculty

The iSchool is pleased to announce that Jingrui He will join the faculty as an associate professor in August 2019. She is currently an associate professor of computer science and engineering at Arizona State University (ASU).

Jingrui He