iSchool team aims to build confidence in computer-generated research results

Bertram Ludäscher
Bertram Ludäscher, Professor and Director, Center for Informatics Research in Science and Scholarship
Timothy McPhillips
Timothy McPhillips, Senior Research Scientist
Craig Willis
Craig Willis, Teaching Assistant Professor

With their nearly completed "Whole Tale" project, Bertram Ludäscher, professor and director of the Center for Informatics Research in Science and Scholarship (CIRSS), and his team have created methods and tools for scientists to link executable computer code, data, and other information to online scholarly publications, which helps ensure reproducibility and paves the way for new discoveries.

Whole Tale aims to build trust in computer-generated results while addressing the problems introduced by evolving computational environments and encountered by individuals using varying computer systems when attempting to recreate results.  The project enables researchers to share "re-runnable" representations of their research, thereby making the resulting publications "living articles" that allow other researchers to examine how computed results originally were obtained and seamlessly recreate those results.

"Any science that uses computers is affected by the computational reproducibility problems that Whole Tale aims to address," said Timothy McPhillips, senior research scientist at CIRSS.

Building on the Whole Tale concept, McPhillips and colleagues Craig Willis and Kacper Kowalik are working with Ludäscher on a new project that will create a certification for computer-generated results when it is not possible for others to recreate results either because the necessary data cannot be shared or specialized computing resources are needed to perform the computations.  Examples of data that might be inaccessible are restricted census data or very large amounts of data gained from satellite streaming.

The goal of the new project, "TRAnsparency CErtified (TRACE): Trusting Computational Research Without Repeating It," is to certify the original execution of a computational workflow that produced findings or data products. The project will create tools that managers of computing centers can use to declare the dimensions of computational transparency supported by their platforms. These tools also will certify that a specific computational workflow was executed on the platform as well as bundle and certify for dissemination artifacts, records of their execution, and technical metadata about their contents.

Collaborating with the iSchool will be Lars Vilhuber, professor of economics at Cornell University and data editor for the journals of the American Economic Association, and Thu-Mai Christian, assistant director for archives at the Odum Institute for Research in Social Science at the University of North Carolina. Both are directly involved in the enforcement of journal policies for research transparency and reproducibility.

"A large number of studies in economics and political science rely on access to confidential or proprietary data that impede or prevent verification. Addressing this is a central goal of TRACE, and we believe that our approach will be broadly applicable to other fields," said Willis.

Part of the project will involve working with stakeholders from varying disciplines, including ecology, bioinformatics, and computer science, to determine what information must be included to earn certification status.

"We need to determine from the stakeholders what would give practitioners in their disciplines confidence that computations were performed as described in a publication," McPhillips said.

The team has been awarded a three-year, $349,999 grant from the National Science Foundation (NSF) for this research.

Updated on
Backto the news archive

Related News

Student says ‘thank you’ with a helicopter ride

Last month, Michael Ferrer showed his appreciation for one of his MSIM instructors in a unique way—by inviting him for an insider’s look at his work as a reservist in the Illinois Army National Guard. For the ILARNG BOSS Lift, which took place on June 18 at Camp Atterbury, Indiana, Ferrer selected Michael Wonderlich, iSchool adjunct lecturer and senior associate director of business intelligence and enterprise architecture for Administrative Information Technology Services (AITS) at the University of Illinois.

Michael Wonderlich and Michael Ferrer hold a U of I flag in front of a military helicopter

Project helps librarians use data storytelling to advocate for public libraries

A toolkit for public librarians can help them use data to communicate the value of their services and justify their funding needs. The Data Storytelling for Librarians Toolkit helps librarians present data in story form using narrative strategies. It was developed by University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign information sciences professors.

Kate McDowell

Chan to deliver keynote at SIGCIS 2024

Associate Professor Anita Say Chan will deliver the keynote at the 15th annual conference of the SHOT (Society for the History of Technology) Special Interest Group for Computing, Information, and Society (SIGCIS), which will be held on July 14 in Viña del Mar, Chile. SIGCIS is the leading international group for historians with an interest in the history of information technology and its applications. The theme for SIGCIS 2024 is "System Update: Patches, Tactics, Responses."

Anita Say Chan

Mattson receives ISTE Making It Happen Award

Adjunct Lecturer Kristen Mattson has received the 2024 International Society for Technology in Education (ISTE) Making It Happen Award. The award honors educators and leaders who demonstrate outstanding commitment, leadership, courage, and persistence in improving digital learning opportunities for students.

Kristen Mattson

NISO publishes Recommended Practice on retracted science

The National Information Standards Organization (NISO) has announced the publication of the Communication of Retractions, Removals, and Expressions of Concern (CREC) Recommended Practice (NISO RP-45-2024), which is the product of a working group made up of cross-industry stakeholders, including Associate Professor Jodi Schneider. 

Jodi Schneider